Do you taste what I taste?

comments 14
Biology / Health / Myths / Zoology

Confession time: I’m just a tad partial to chocolate. I blame my Dad who also qualifies as a chocoholic. But I’ll never forget a chocolate experience I had almost 20 years ago when I was given the opportunity to try some Gymnema sylvestre. Some what you say? It’s a herb, native to Indian and Sri Lankan forest that suppresses your ability to taste sweetness. And eating chocolate straight after the herb was extremely offputting. The chocolate had virtually no taste but had the texture of wax, or maybe soap. I could feel it coating my tongue and teeth and I couldn’t imagine ever wanting to eat chocolate again. That’s the power of our taste buds.

Cats taste differently to humans. for one thing, they can't detect sweetness. Image credit Susan E Adams via Flickr

A cat’s sense of taste is different to ours. For one thing, they can’t detect sweetness. Image credit Susan E Adams via Flickr

The famous five

You didn’t know it, but you were already developing preferences for particular flavours before you were even born. The food flavours you were introduced to in the amniotic fluid you were surrounded by before birth influenced you, as did the diversity of flavours in breast milk if you were breastfed.

These days you probably take for granted that you can taste a massive variety of flavours. But in fact, you have only taste buds that respond to five distinct tastes: sour, bitter, salty, umami (savoury) and sweet. Some researchers argue that fat should be considered a sixth primary taste.

At a basic level, your taste buds are there to make sure you eat nutritious things and avoid poisons. Each of your taste buds contains a group of 50 to 150 taste receptor cells that look a bit like a tightly-closed bunch of bananas. Taste receptor cells sample the food molecules in your mouth and report a sensation of taste to your brain. The complex flavours you taste are a result of both the taste and smell of food.

If you have a close look at your tongue in the mirror, you’ll notice lots of little pale bumps all over the surface. These are called fungiform papillae. Your taste buds are too small to see without a microscope but they can be found on these papillae. There are also taste buds on the roof of your mouth and on your throat. And you’ve got somewhere between eight and ten thousand taste buds which are replaced about every two weeks.

Are you a super-taster?

We used to think different parts of the tongue handled different tastes – for example that receptors for sweet were located on the tongue tip and the bitter region was at the back of the tongue. But we’ve known since 1974 that all taste buds can detect each of the five basic flavours.

What does differ though is the number of taste buds each person has. If you’ve got a particularly picky eater in your family, consider there may be something more than fussiness going on. Some people have many more taste buds than others and therefore have much stronger likes and dislikes of foods. These people are termed ‘super-tasters’.

If you’re one of the 15 to 21% of people who can’t bear to eat coriander and say it tastes like soap you can blame it on your genes. Researchers have identified several genes involved in taste and smell that seem to be responsible for peoples’ complete hate of the herb.

Of birds and cats

You are most likely accustomed to enjoying the full range of tastes but recent research has shown that not all animals get to enjoy the same diversity of flavours.

It seems penguins can only taste sour and salty and have completely lost the ability to detect sweet, bitter or umami flavours. Researchers worked this out when studying penguin DNA. They were looking for the genes that enable taste buds to pick up each of the five different tastes and found a number were missing. It’s possible this ability was lost as a result of penguins living in very cold environments. Research suggests receptors for these three tastes don’t work at very cold temperatures so over evolutionary time the genes have been lost. It was probably important that penguins maintained their ability to taste salt so they could keep track of their salt intake from the ocean and being able to taste sour would help a penguin avoid rotten food. But beyond that it seems a penguin’s palate is not tuned to fine dining.

In fact, research suggests all birds have lost their ability to taste sweetness. But in a fascinating twist scientists have found that hummingbirds, specialist nectar feeders, have repurposed their umami receptors so they can taste sweet.

And it isn’t just birds that have lost the capacity to taste sweetness. Unlike almost all other mammals studied to date, cats don’t have the ability to taste sweetness. Presumably being able to taste sweet is of little value if you never eat any fruit or vegetables. Tigers, lions, panthers, your tabby at home, none of them can taste sweetness.

Being able to taste the delicious sweetness of chocolate brings me so much joy I’m glad I’m not a cat. Because as I discovered all those years ago, chocolate without sweetness just isn’t chocolate. No thanks.

Links and stuff

Radio on demand

 This post accompanies a radio segment on Triple R’s Breakfasters program on Wednesday 27 May 2015. 

14 Comments

  1. Absolutely fascinating! I love your posts and always learn so much. Thank you. I’m sitting in Serendipity in Las Vegas and about to give my taste buds a work out 🙂

  2. Fascinating! I would be very interested to know if chickens (the bird that took over the world!) have indeed lost a taste for sweetness. Mine love grapes and watermelon and are distinctly not keen on citrus – if it’s not the sweet flavour at stake I wonder about the appeal….

    • Fascinating isn’t it. Same with cats – everyone reports their pet cat loves sweet stuff but if our genetic understanding is right, they can’t taste the sweetness. I’ve just been doing some searching to see what I can find out about chickens. Lots of anecdotal reports they don’t taste much and a scientist is reported here http://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2010/08/12/2980854.htm as saying they only have 30 taste buds. But that doesn’t tell us what flavours their taste buds are receptive to!

      • I’d be very interested to read more about that! Anecdotal evidence to support the “chickens can’t taste much” theory – they absolutely love eating polystyrene foam. As someone said on a chicken blog somewhere “It’s like crack to them”. Obviously I try to keep them away from it, but it does suggest that it’s all about the beak-feel!!

  3. I’ll definitely do that! I am really interested in animal senses and, prompted by the odd things I have seen in my backyard, have done a couple of posts on the topic – about chickens’ night sight ( https://berowrabackyard.wordpress.com/2014/05/15/twilight-of-the-chickens/ ) and on possum colour vision ( https://berowrabackyard.wordpress.com/2014/03/27/do-possums-see-in-technicolour/ ). I was surprised to find that marsupial colour vision was a bit of a hot bed of recent research, and that there wasn’t an easily accessible public account of whether brushtailed possums, as super common backyard beasties, could see in colour. (perhaps these are niche preoccupations!!) There might be now – Lisa Vlahos did a PhD on it in 2013, with the very cute name of “Possum Magic”! But digging around on the topic made me think about the many observations of the behaviour of common animals that are probably out there but aren’t necessarily connected in any way to “proper” academic research. There seems to be more use of citizen scientists in the area of ornithology… maybe this divide will become less dramatic in time with work like yours?

    • Thanks so much for your comments – I’m looking forward to reading your posts. I also find animal (and indeed) human senses fascinating as you’ve probably gathered by some of the topics I’ve chosen to talk/ write about. And the possum question is an interesting one. I spent 10+ years researching mountain brushtail possums (including my PhdD) so I’ve thought a lot about how they sense the world around them. I don’t have any answers though!!

  4. You said “At a basic level, your taste buds are there to make sure you eat nutritious things and avoid poisons.” – then what’s with that smelly fruit they eat in Asia – what taste bud in their right kind would go for that stuff.

    I also take note of the ‘super taster’ and think of my youngest daughter and her food pickiness – Mind you, I’m not showing her this article. She’ll not only claim she’s one of them, but she’ll conduct an experiment on the whole family where by we would have to subject our tongues to a taste bud count. Shh!

    • The supertaster thing is interesting in terms of kids who are fussy eaters. I wonder how often, if ever, that is the explanation. And hey, you know you want to do the blue dye/ counting taste buds experiment 😉

  5. Presumably dogs have an ability to taste sweet things? They quite like chocolate (No, I’m not feeding chocolate to dogs, just making an observation), sugary things and diary products, given half a chance. Of course, they aren’t strictly carnivorous like felines, which might be why they’re happy to eat almost anything. And some are naturally more fussy than others; not every dog is a vacuum cleaner on legs. 🙂

    • Yes, dogs can definitely taste sweet. I would assume because as definite omnivores dogs have probably always supplemented their diet with fruit and pretty much anything else edible they could find! But yes, I have heard of fussy dogs too!

  6. Pingback: The look of concentration | Espresso Science

  7. Pingback: A dead-end trap crop | Berowra backyard

Please, let me know what you think.

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s